CinderpointSportsworksDASHFRAME › DASH II
DASHFRAME · Module 2 · Post-Capture

The DASH II Protocol

By Waydell D. Carvalho  ·  Cinderpoint  ·  First published 2025
Definition
DASH II extends the DASH framework past the point of entry. It diagnoses sportshandling: the phase in which an actor that has already entered sport consolidates control through governance dependence, market closure, narrative monopoly, and weak remedies. Its core instrument is the P.C.R. (Post-Capture Risk) Model, a five-question, 0 to 3 scoring tool with a composite range of 0 to 15.

Sportswashing buys acceptance. Sportshandling manages permanence.

DASH I covered how authoritarian or monopolistic actors enter sport. DASH II covers what they do once they are inside. Governance codes, broadcast contracts, and competition rules turn into instruments for narrative containment. The appearance of reform masks structural dependency. This is a different failure mode and it needs its own diagnostic.

The five P.C.R. questions

Q1
Narrative Dominance
Who controls the storytelling ecosystem around governance and competition?
Q2
Governance Dependence
Are integrity and oversight bodies structurally autonomous, or financially captive?
Q3
Market Closure
Do licensing or competition rules restrict entry, mobility, or accountability?
Q4
Data and Revenue Leverage
Is information or capital flow used to entrench influence?
Q5
Rights and Remedies
Do athletes, clubs, and fans have independent means of redress?

The cases

DASH II was tested on five cases chosen to represent the full spectrum of sportshandling: FIFA, illustrating cyclical recapture of oversight after reform. MLS and the U.S. Soccer Federation, demonstrating market closure inside a democratic system. The NBA, showing how revenue dependence produces voluntary censorship. The IOC and Formula 1, exemplifying sponsor-state co-dependence and perpetual event capture. The Bundesliga 50+1 rule as a low-risk control case where member ownership prevents capture in the first place.

What the model surfaces

Sportshandling thrives where information asymmetry prevents scrutiny, regulator and regulated overlap, economic closure protects incumbents, narrative monopolies neutralize criticism, and remedies are weak or non-existent. P.C.R. translates those theoretical conditions into something a regulator, a league, or a fan group can actually score on a deal in front of them.

How DASH I and DASH II combine

Together the two protocols form a lifecycle model of legitimacy risk in global sport: from ingress to control, from image to institution. DASH I tells you what is being let in. DASH II tells you what it has become.

Cite this protocol
Carvalho, W. D. (2025). D.A.S.H. II: Defeating Authoritarian Sportshandling and Post-Capture Control. Cinderpoint. https://cinderpoint.com/sportsworks/dashframe/dash-ii/
About the author
Waydell D. Carvalho

Founder of Cinderpoint Systems LLC. M.S. Artificial Intelligence (MSAI), M.S. Management (MSM). Researches how systems fail under speed, opacity, and scale.

More by this author SSRN ↗